| Year | Eagle Scout | Year | Eagle Scout | Year | Eagle Scout |
| 2009 | Andrew Cihak | 1990 | Ed Hildebrand | 1971 | Pelham Rozelle |
| 2009 | Ryan Chan | 1990 | Jim Place | 1971 | Rynn Parsons |
| 2009 | Spencer Rowell | 1987 | Dan Mulchay | 1970 | Bill Reid |
| 2009 | Skyler Carter | 1986 | Ron Linfoot Jr. | 1970 | Hal Ehrhardt |
| 2008 |
William Pipher |
1986 | Steve Savage | 1970 | Michael Arnold |
| 2006 | Andy Foley | 1984 | Jens Curtis | 1969 | David Kerr |
| 2006 | Andy Stifel | 1984 | Mike Dubois | 1969 | Jeff Gregg |
| 2006 | Daniel Higham | 1984 | Tom Million | 1968 | Dale Capra |
| 2006 | Tyler Vandervort | 1984 | Tom Walsh | 1967 | Jon Nus |
| 2003 | David Penny | 1983 | Gregg Estey | 1967 | Robert Leamer |
| 2003 | Jon Floyd | 1983 | Lynn Terry | 1967 | Tom Halbert |
| 2003 | Jon Sprousse | 1981 | Frank Benecken | 1966 | Doug Kerr |
| 2003 | Matt Miller | 1981 | Karl Browne | 1965 | Fred Heichman III |
| 2002 | Brent Fairbrother | 1981 | Kevin Savage | 1965 | Rodney Moore |
| 2002 | Tim Warneck | 1979 | Eric Dubois | 1964 | Keith Deans |
| 2000 | Brian Ehrhardt | 1979 | John Linfoot | 1962 | Alan Miller |
| 2000 | Chris Garner | 1979 | Ted Plase | 1962 | David Scott |
| 2000 | Jim Warneck | 1979 | Tom Anderson | 1961 | Dean Morgan |
| 2000 | Joel Miller | 1978 | Bruce Morrison | 1961 | James Scheer |
| 2000 | Michael McMahon | 1978 | Doug Rose | 1961 | Phil Alley |
| 1999 | Kyle Melligan | 1978 | Joe Robinson | 1961 | Robert Ambrose |
| 1999 | Lucas Vandervort | 1978 | Jon Beck | 1960 | Charles Alsup |
| 1999 | Ray Standish | 1978 | Mike Montalto | 1960 | Richard Carmody |
| 1999 | Scott Homer | 1977 | Chris Connors | 1959 | Carl Kocian |
| 1998 | Jason Elsner | 1977 | Jim Vicks | 1959 | Ed Leamer |
| 1998 | Matt Paushter | 1977 | Rick Hook | 1959 | Jon Reimer |
| 1998 | Tom Wilson | 1976 | Mike Fairbrother | 1959 | Larry Kerr |
| 1997 | Peter Warneck | 1976 | Randy Walker | 1958 | Charles Place |
| 1997 | Scott Hessian | 1975 | Paul Shepter | 1958 | Gary Doupe |
| 1996 | Andy Meagher | 1975 | Stann Disbro | 1958 | Robert Currie |
| 1996 | Ray Pierce | 1973 | Bob Fairbrother | 1956 | Hal Williams |
| 1996 | Scott Beirle | 1973 | Dave Burger | 1956 | Richard Place |
| 1995 | Eric Howe | 1973 | David Anderson | 1953 | Gary Hartman |
| 1995 | Jake Dempsey | 1973 | Gavin Kerr | 1953 | Gary O'Connor |
| 1995 | Jason Guy | 1973 | Howard Dingman | 1953 | James McQueen |
| 1995 | Joe Cuda | 1973 | Jim Kattell | 1953 | Thomas Way |
| 1995 | Josh Miller | 1973 | Ken Tomko | 1952 | Bob Letson |
| 1994 | Dan Petrush | 1973 | Mark Bespalko | 1952 | Robert Morrison |
| 1994 | Dave Petrush | 1973 | Michael Weil | 1952 | Robert Reynolds |
| 1992 | Gregg Mydosh | 1973 | Mike Bunzey | 1951 | Craig Johnson |
| 1992 | John Sacco | 1973 | Mike Vicks | 1951 | Robert Anderson |
| 1992 | Josh Collins | 1973 | Pete Lombardi | 1948 | Blaine Ellis |
| 1992 | Matt Place | 1973 | Richard Weil | 1948 | Clyde Thompson |
| 1992 | Mike Ondik | 1973 | Stephen Montalto | 1948 | Frank Brown |
| 1991 | Alec Thate | 1972 | Glenn Rinne | 1948 | Norman Spence |
| 1990 | Dan Ihnot | 1972 | Sam Lansing | 1947 | Ken Schep |